1. Opinion
  2. Indigenous

Opinion: Canada is breaking its promise to thousands of dead and missing Indigenous children

The government has dramatically scaled back a program aimed at assisting communities in documenting burial sites near former residential schools — placing vital work in jeopardy
Written by Roberta Hill and Laura Arndt
Steps leading up to the site of former the Mohawk Institute in Brantford on November 9, 2021, as phase one of a ground search begins for unmarked graves. (Nick Iwanyshyn/CP)

Today is Canada’s National Day of Truth and Reconciliation. We have been marking this day since 2021. That was also when the federal government created the Residential Schools Missing Children Community Support Fund to support Indigenous communities, organizations, and families “as they seek to research, locate, and document burial sites associated with former residential schools, as well as to memorialize deaths of children and return children's remains home.” This was a promise to us that our search for the truth would be honoured and supported. We hoped it would be kept. And for a while it was.

Over the first three years, the fund supported the work of 144 Indigenous communities from across Canada. That work, accessing obscure records in multiple jurisdictions, finding graves had never been marked, is complex, laborious, and painful. But it is underway. Except now, the government has dramatically reduced the funding — from $216.6 million over three years to $91 million over two — without any consultation or advance warning. This places in dire jeopardy the work that is now being done and makes it impossible for any other communities to even consider getting started.

The government of Canada and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau are breaking their promise to thousands of dead and missing children. In the name of those children, we urge them to reconsider.

It is ironic that we should issue a plea in the name of thousands of children, because we don’t actually know all their names. That is part of the problem. An estimated 150,000 Indigenous children, some as young as four, were taken from their homes — many by force — and placed in Canada’s Indian Residential Schools between 1828 and 1996. They were abused and malnourished, with some subject to “nutrition experiments.” They were punished for speaking their Indigenous languages. Many were traumatized. And thousands never made it home. It is hard to decide which is more shocking — that thousands of children died while attending residential schools or that we have no idea what the real number is. There are estimates of 6,000. Many believe it is more. Nobody knows the truth.

How can a country like Canada live comfortably with an open wound like uncounted thousands of missing children? The answer is that no country should accept something like this, but ours sometimes seems as if it does. We are with the Survivors’ Secretariat, a not-for-profit organization representing the survivors of the Mohawk Institute, Canada’s longest-running Indian Residential School. One of us is a survivor, and the other the daughter of a survivor.

And on behalf of every child who was taken away, those who made it back home, and those who did not, on behalf of their families and communities, we are calling on the Canadian government to keep its promise and keep helping us find the truth.

Just one year ago, six months before the budget that cut our funding, Prime Minister Trudeau said, “As communities continue searching for the children who never came home, the Government of Canada will be there every step of the way to provide them with the resources they need to fully uncover the truth of what happened at residential schools, honour the children who did not return, and support communities as they continue on their healing journeys.”

On this day, the Survivors’ Secretariat is releasing a report capturing the growing anger and frustration of survivors, Indigenous leaders, and experts over the government’s sudden decision to break its promise.

Prime Minister, fine words are not enough. And promises matter only when you keep them. So keep your promise. Do it for our communities. Do it for this country, so it may know real reconciliation. Do it for the survivors of those terrible schools. Do it for the children who died, whose names we don’t even know.